In the last 10 years, the exchange-traded fund (ETF) has become one of the most popular investment vehicles. An ETF is a type of security that tracks an index, bonds, commodities, currencies, or a mix of various asset classes.
Because it is a type of fund, the ETF is often compared to the mutual fund when weighing the pros and cons of various investment vehicles. Both an ETF and a mutual fund hold a portfolio of investments whether they are stocks, bonds, or other assets.
Furthermore, both fall under the same regulations, depending on the assets that they hold in their portfolios.
Despite some similarities, however, both also have their differences. Below are some key differences between ETFs and mutual funds.
More Dynamic and Cost Efficient
The ETF owns underlying assets and divides ownership of those assets into shares. As such, these shares can be bought and sold on a major exchange.
Furthermore, because of this flexibility, they can be traded intraday. This allows investors to trade them through online or traditional brokers.
Mutual funds shares are bought and sold directly through the mutual fund company, so the actions of other fund investors can affect an individual investor’s tax liability.
An ETF shareholder is also entitled to income earned through dividends. In the event the fund is liquidated, ETF shareholders may also receive a portion of its residual value, which is the value determined at the end of an asset’s useful life.
Because an ETF can track an index, it can be passively-managed. This translates to lower costs to investors when compared to mutual funds, which are typically actively-managed.
Actively-managed mutual funds carry greater operating costs because they have to pay analysts and other research specialists. The lower costs of ETFs show in their expense ratio, which is the cost to run the fund.
Different Creation Process
The process of creation and redemption is what regulates the supply of ETFs. This process will involve an authorized participant (AP) who can redeem shares of an ETF via sale to the fund’s sponsor.
Market demand will be the primary determinant for the amount of redemption and creation activity. Demand for the ETF will also drive the price of its shares, which in turn, determines whether the ETF is trading at a discount or premium relative to the value of its underlying assets.
Less Taxable Events
The ETF is often praised for their tax efficiency since they use an in-kind exchange with an authorized participant. This means an ETF manager uses an exchange to sell the basket of stocks in a fund.
This allows the authorized participant to shoulder the impact of capital gains taxes. As mentioned, a mutual fund that must sell stocks in order to cover redemptions. This creates a scenario where the fund pays capital gains taxes that are passed on to the investor.
Certain ETF products could be subject to capital gains taxes, such as actively-managed funds. For these funds, a higher degree of buying or selling could result in more capital gains taxes incurred.
Still, most ETFs sell holdings only when the factors affecting their underlying index change. This results in a lower turnover ratio that creates taxable events.
As per investor data, some actively-managed mutual funds have a turnover rate of 100 percent. In contrast, the majority of ETFs have a turnover rate that is less than 10 percent.
Phantom gains consist of capital gains that an investor owes taxes even if the actual return realized on the investment results in a negative return. In the world of mutual funds, phantom gains can occur when an investor purchases shares of a mutual fund before a fund manager sells a large portion of holdings.
The fund manager’s sale of the holdings creates a taxable event. As such, any capital gains realized on the sale are then passed on to mutual fund investors.
Because of the way ETFs are structured, they do not expose themselves to these phantom gains. Securities within an ETF portfolio are exchanged and created through an in-kind exchange.
This results in the securities returned on a low-cost basis and received at a higher cost basis, which limits tax liability. This results in lower capital gains taxes as opposed to a mutual fund engaging in a similar transaction.
Different Legal Structure
The tax efficiency of ETFs is inherent in their legal structure as opposed to a mutual fund. Most ETFs are structured as open-end funds, which fall under the regulatory measures of the Investment Company Act of 1940.
In essence, an individual tax investor doesn’t have control of the actions of his or her fellow mutual fund investors. In addition, a mutual fund manager must sell a portion of the fund’s holdings for shares redeemed, which could result in capital gains.
Those capital gains realized are then passed on to mutual fund investors. ETFs are not exposed to this type of taxable event.
The tax implications for ETFs can also vary according to their legal structure. A tax professional can help an investor navigate through the tax ramifications for each type of ETF structure.
Seven Types of ETF Structures:
- Open-end funds: this structure is typically used for stock and bond asset classes.
- Unit investment trusts: typically used to track broad asset classes.
- Grantor trusts: typically used for physical commodities and currencies.
- Exchange-traded notes: don’t hold underlying assets, but contain prepaid forward contracts.
- Partnerships: unincorporated business entities that elect for taxation as a partnership.
- C Corporations: used to access specific types of partnerships as well as other special purpose vehicles (SPVs).
- Exchange-traded managed funds: meld the active component of mutual funds with the intraday trading flexibility of an ETF.
The majority of ETFs are structured as open-end funds, which fall under the regulatory measures of the Investment Company Act of 1940. These types of ETFs typically provide investor’s exposure to the most common assets, which are stocks and bonds.
Have more questions? Contact us at email@example.com